Comments on: American Idol – top 3 review

By: daryl

daryl — Thu, 18 Feb 2010 01:02:18 +0000

I see you stay away from making a judgement on there singing ability.Smart it could cost you students. Well singing is a subjective judgement. I use to sing i now have pitch problems and i refuse to sing even in the shower. I can not stand to hear anyone sing off key. Mostly myself.
I suggest you become a judge on American Idol. That would be fair result show. It would be based on singing ability and presents.

By: Anna-belle hebert

Anna-belle hebert — Mon, 25 May 2009 00:16:19 +0000

yeah true. but im sure Adam will go far. he is an amazing artist.

By: Ray Minkle

Ray Minkle — Sun, 24 May 2009 23:43:14 +0000

I agree totally with Per about Adam. He is the REAL deal. He has iconic status already in my book and he will usher in a new generation of MEGA SONG STARS. I am from Arkansas and loved the freshness of Kris but I am and will continue to be a bigger fan of Adams and look forward to his future success. I also think that Kris showed lots of growth and maturity and at the end of the day, his fresh Christian appearance appealed to more of the voting public. That is what happens when you go with subjective popularity. We will see in the LONG RUN who is the brightest shinning star.

By: Anna-belle hebert

Anna-belle hebert — Sun, 24 May 2009 22:50:49 +0000

i think that America made a mistake to not have voted for Adam… Adam is amazing. he always gets my attention he know how to captivate peoples attention. he will be in the buisness for a long time. i dont think that people have complaint about american idol in like forever… this year was a big deal. And i think that kris is too much like very artist. some people say that he will be the new john mayer. but im not a huge fan of john mayer and there is too many look alikes in the buisness… but anyway… congrats to both.

By: Lori Greif

Lori Greif — Sun, 17 May 2009 02:52:36 +0000

Adam Lambert IS an “American Idol”. He is not just a singer, he is a well rounded performer and artist. A polished performer who has devoted his growing years preparing and studying for this moment. The other remaining two, Kris and Danny (now off the show)are not in his league. I wish I could vote for Adam, but I do not live in the States.Thank you Per for your professional comments & analysis of these singers.

By: mand

mand — Sat, 16 May 2009 23:14:32 +0000

well said Ray ! Adam Lambert is definitely the high light of AI this year even if he doesn,t win he,s the winner in my book i am surprised kris has made it this far, i personally connected more with Alison but this competition is down to the people who pick up the phone and vote hopefully they will all go far good luck to them all !

By: Ray Minkle

Ray Minkle — Sat, 16 May 2009 19:50:28 +0000

I have to totally agree with Per on his observations. It was like he was listening to me comment as I watched the show. I am from Arkansas and Kris winning would be fun for the state but without a doubt, Adam is the best AI contestant we have seen. He is “the total package”. I have only seen the show for the last 3 weeks. I am sorry I did not tune in earlier. Kris is just such a wonderful young man with just the freshest face and humble persona. Because of this I would not be surprised if he won but Adam Lambert is without a doubt the STAR of this decade.