Comments on: American Idol Review – Top 7 – To Own The Stage Or Not http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/ Tips, Advice, News on Voice, Communication & Performance Sun, 29 Jan 2012 01:49:39 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: Daniel S. http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1291 Daniel S. Wed, 23 Apr 2008 18:24:12 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1291 David Cook--I agree that "As daring and unique his vocal arrangement of the song was, his performance was anything but daring and unique." which ties into your further comments that he needs to get out from behind the mic and engage the audience. Of course he isn't Mick Jaggar but if you compare performances between the two, it is obvious that David has a lot of growing to do. His voice and what my wife calls "sexy eyes" are only going to take him so far. David Cook–I agree that “As daring and unique his vocal arrangement of the song was, his performance was anything but daring and unique.” which ties into your further comments that he needs to get out from behind the mic and engage the audience. Of course he isn’t Mick Jaggar but if you compare performances between the two, it is obvious that David has a lot of growing to do. His voice and what my wife calls “sexy eyes” are only going to take him so far.

]]> By: Robin F http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1280 Robin F Wed, 23 Apr 2008 03:01:31 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1280 David A and Syesha are boooring, even thought they both are technically good singers. Jason is definitely not the best singer, but he's just so likable and charming he pulls it off every time. Brooke and Kristy both got old with me very quick. Carly can sing too but sometimes she screams instead of sings. She looks scary sometimes. David C is the whole package. Has he had a a single bad performance really? David A and Syesha are boooring, even thought they both are technically good singers. Jason is definitely not the best singer, but he’s just so likable and charming he pulls it off every time. Brooke and Kristy both got old with me very quick. Carly can sing too but sometimes she screams instead of sings. She looks scary sometimes. David C is the whole package. Has he had a a single bad performance really?

]]> By: auctionmaven http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1273 auctionmaven Tue, 22 Apr 2008 15:03:30 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1273 I actually like David Cook a lot; I sense a certain reserve in him that I felt was a reaction to what must seem like the utter unreality of the situation, but I feel that he's a very honest performer and enjoy him a great deal. Not very fond of Jason Castro as he seems quite bland to me, and something about David A. just doesn't seem to ring right, but I can't put my finger on it. I actually like David Cook a lot; I sense a certain reserve in him that I felt was a reaction to what must seem like the utter unreality of the situation, but I feel that he’s a very honest performer and enjoy him a great deal. Not very fond of Jason Castro as he seems quite bland to me, and something about David A. just doesn’t seem to ring right, but I can’t put my finger on it.

]]> By: Mrs. Mucsician http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1263 Mrs. Mucsician Mon, 21 Apr 2008 21:42:32 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1263 Leona version on the song was so much better. The rest of the girls were ok, I really didnt like the guys singing MC Leona version on the song was so much better. The rest of the girls were ok, I really didnt like the guys singing MC

]]> By: Ronda http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1262 Ronda Mon, 21 Apr 2008 20:56:40 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1262 Though David A. has a beautiful voice I find him boring and predictable. Ballads and slow songs seem to be all he can sing. David C. is by far my favorite. I don't buy that he is stealing other peoples songs , I think it is more the judges not being aware of these different versions. They are introduced as so and so's version of a particular song before he sings them. Carly is extremely talented , just seems to be trying to hard. The others to me are all about equal. Though David A. has a beautiful voice I find him boring and predictable. Ballads and slow songs seem to be all he can sing.
David C. is by far my favorite. I don’t buy that he is stealing other peoples songs , I think it is more the judges not being aware of these different versions. They are introduced as so and so’s version of a particular song before he sings them.
Carly is extremely talented , just seems to be trying to hard.
The others to me are all about equal.

]]> By: Lisa http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1258 Lisa Mon, 21 Apr 2008 15:52:48 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1258 While I agree that David Cook tends to "hide" behind the mic stand, I have to say that his singing blows me away 9 times out of 10. I think he has the potential to go all the way. The girls are holding their own but I think this year it might be a Man's game. While I agree that David Cook tends to “hide” behind the mic stand, I have to say that his singing blows me away 9 times out of 10. I think he has the potential to go all the way. The girls are holding their own but I think this year it might be a Man’s game.

]]> By: Austin Long http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1253 Austin Long Mon, 21 Apr 2008 05:21:17 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1253 Great advice for David. He's a hometown hero (well Murray, Utah is 25 miles away but we still all support him) and we wish him the best too. But this is true about his connection with the audience and I think that's wise feedback. He's still a kid and may never have had his first kiss. I hope he can keep the good things while he grows up! Great advice for David. He’s a hometown hero (well Murray, Utah is 25 miles away but we still all support him) and we wish him the best too. But this is true about his connection with the audience and I think that’s wise feedback.

He’s still a kid and may never have had his first kiss. I hope he can keep the good things while he grows up!

]]> By: Norina B http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1250 Norina B Mon, 21 Apr 2008 01:52:22 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1250 I think the guys did a really great job doing the Mariah Carey songs. I'm getting bored with Brooke but David A is so cute and has a great voice. I do keeping thinking that David would be great on the Disney Channel. I think the guys did a really great job doing the Mariah Carey songs. I’m getting bored with Brooke but David A is so cute and has a great voice. I do keeping thinking that David would be great on the Disney Channel.

]]> By: PJ http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1248 PJ Mon, 21 Apr 2008 01:16:41 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1248 I really don't like Mariah Carey so this was a hard week to watch. I think Brooke and Kristy Lee were the two best, but it was obviously time for Kristy Lee to go. Of the guys, David Cook is the best but he may not get the votes of the teen girls who are keeping Archuleta and Jason safe no matter what they sing. Anyway, it is a fun show to watch every week and I like all of the top 10 finalists. I really don’t like Mariah Carey so this was a hard week to watch. I think Brooke and Kristy Lee were the two best, but it was obviously time for Kristy Lee to go. Of the guys, David Cook is the best but he may not get the votes of the teen girls who are keeping Archuleta and Jason safe no matter what they sing. Anyway, it is a fun show to watch every week and I like all of the top 10 finalists.

]]> By: Evan Leitch http://www.perbristow.com/71/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not/comment-page-2/#comment-1247 Evan Leitch Mon, 21 Apr 2008 00:02:49 +0000 http://www.perbristow.com/american-idol-review-top-7-to-own-the-stage-or-not.htm#comment-1247 it was a great and funny show it was a great and funny show

]]>